We’ll always have Sacramento

One problem with good-government schemes designed to oust political people from control of political matters is that they can’t.  Even if political tasks like judicial selection or legislative redistricting are entrusted to panels of eminent persons, the eminent persons remain captive to human nature. Let’s not kid ourselves.

These thoughts are occasioned by the cyclical pleas seen last week in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, for an eminent persons’ panel to draw state legislative districts.

The editors find it troubling that Republicans won five of eight Wisconsin congressional seats last November while Democrats collected about 1.5 percent more of all congressional votes statewide.  As redistricting outrages go, this is pale tea; It’s hardly an indictment of Republicans if voters in Democrat-leaning districts (perhaps seeing government as the center of their universe,) give their candidates fatter margins.

And it’s awkward for the editors—who object to the concentration of each party’s voters in “safe” districts—when they criticize Republicans’ $400,000 legal expenses defending the district lines they drew for Hispanic areas in Milwaukee. Presumably the editors know the GOP mapmakers were sued precisely because—according to the plaintiffs—they hadn’t concentrated Hispanic voters enough.

Who does it better? California, where “voters in 2008 turned redistricting over to an independent group of citizens. The result: more contested races.” We suppose it would be bad manners to mention that, sanitized redistricting or not, the California Legislature is in the process of doubling down on bankruptcy.  To paraphrase “Casablanca,” we wouldn’t bring up California if we were you; it’s poor salesmanship.

The editors settle the question themselves by admonishing Assembly Speaker Robin Vos (R-Burlington) that “one day the shoe will be on the other foot.” If that’s true, as undoubtedly it is, it will prove the system works.


About Wisconsin Club for Growth
The Club for Growth is a national network of over 40,000 men and women, from all walks of life, who believe that prosperity and opportunity come through economic freedom. Wisconsin Club for Growth, Inc. is dedicated to informing, educating and rallying citizens of Wisconsin to embrace and enact policies that lead to sustained economic growth, limited government, and minimal taxation. Wisconsin Club for Growth can and will have an enormous impact on the direction of our state. Wisconsin Club for Growth believes that effective lobbying is done at all stages of the budget cycle, including when our leaders make public promises and can be encouraged to support policies that spur economic growth. Wisconsin Club for Growth believes we must support pro-growth policies and encourage public officials with backbones to remain truly committed to making our economy and our state stronger. Wisconsin Club for Growth believes our leaders must stand up to the tax and spend mentality in Madison and work tirelessly to cut taxes and unleash the power of the free-market.

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: